SlingPlayer Mobile for iPhone coming shortly: $29.99, no 3G support
After what has become one of the longer (and certainly one of the highest-profile) App Store approval delays, SlingPlayer Mobile for iPhone has finally gotten Apple's blessing -- with some serious changes under the hood. Most importantly, 3G access has been disabled, meaning you'll only be able to get your Sling on over WiFi -- a serious blow to the app and a huge change from the way SlingPlayer Mobile works on other platforms -- and likely a verification that either Apple or AT&T took serious issue with the bandwidth load imposed by this type of app on the HSPA network. Despite the restriction, Sling will be charging a whopping $29.99 for the download; in exchange for your troubles, though, they've decided to lift the ban on older Slingboxes, with the caveat that they won't be officially supported if you run into trouble.
We've had a chance to play with the app, and it certainly gets the job done -- we just wish it worked a little better. Even on WiFi, control feels laggy, and there's no native guide (though there's an icon to quickly pull up your set-top box's guide). When you're in letterbox mode, you've got black bars around all four sides of the image, meaning that the app isn't taking full advantage of the phone's display; we're hopeful this'll be fixed in a future release, though. Happily, we think Sling really nailed the app's UI -- the on-screen translucent controls are pretty cool and generally work well without obscuring the view. Look to grab your own copy some time between 12:01AM and 6:01AM EDT tomorrow morning, and in the meantime, check out our gallery.
We've had a chance to play with the app, and it certainly gets the job done -- we just wish it worked a little better. Even on WiFi, control feels laggy, and there's no native guide (though there's an icon to quickly pull up your set-top box's guide). When you're in letterbox mode, you've got black bars around all four sides of the image, meaning that the app isn't taking full advantage of the phone's display; we're hopeful this'll be fixed in a future release, though. Happily, we think Sling really nailed the app's UI -- the on-screen translucent controls are pretty cool and generally work well without obscuring the view. Look to grab your own copy some time between 12:01AM and 6:01AM EDT tomorrow morning, and in the meantime, check out our gallery.
























Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
kcmurphy88 @ May 12th 2009 1:44PM
Another reason to bypass 3G is that the app is then identical on iPhone and iPod Touch. Considering that there are 37 million iPhone/Touch units sold, this is a big market for Sling.
darklighter @ May 12th 2009 2:04PM
I haven't looked at the iPhone SDK, but my assumption is that the network APIs don't differentiate between 3G and WiFi for that very reason. It doesn't take extra work to make the app portable; it takes extra work to disable 3G.
Eric @ May 12th 2009 2:58PM
So disappointed it doesn't have 3G. 90% of the places I would use slingbox mobile are places where there isn't any wifi. I probably would have purchased it for the ridiculous $30 price if it had 3G, now I'm going to have to pass.
David Hildreth @ May 12th 2009 3:41PM
There are some apps you can get on a jailbroken phone to trick Wifi apps into working on 3G. It doesn't work for everything, but you can bet people will make an effort to get compatibility for this.
Gilbert @ May 13th 2009 4:57AM
You can get the orb live iphone app for 9.99 This app can be used on the 3g and edge network along with wifi. I use it on my touch. I stream my hauppauge tv tuner card through the free pc orb client. It works great. Its sad to see such a high price on the sling player. I just hope that apple doesn't make orb take out the orb live 3g support in a future update.
nz @ May 12th 2009 4:45PM
The App Store is going to be the downfall of Apple. We live in a world where we require our companies to be open and responsive. Apple has never been "open" and it is worked fabulously for them. I just don't see it continuing with decisions like this.
With WiFi-only, the Sling App is pretty much worthless. I am rarely around WiFi when I am not at home, in which case I'll just turn on the TV.
What would lead to this decision?
AT&T allows other phones to stream Sling content over 3G.
Apple wants to make money and has no good reason, short of battery life considerations, to exclude an app that streams video.
Sling will realize the mistake of not including 3G right away, but have no control over that.
My only thought is that AT&T has a similar app for uVerse and they are trying to limit the competition.
I don't even own a Slingbox and it is frustrating!
kcmurphy88 @ May 12th 2009 7:16PM
I'd guess that iPod Touch users have more use for this, then.
Bill @ May 12th 2009 5:16PM
again, I repeat what I said on the engadget mobile article too,
F U AT&T
Mike @ May 12th 2009 6:34PM
Yep, I'm passing too.
I am REALLY starting to hate my iPhone. What I mean by that is I hate AT&T. If I was ever alone with the CEO of AT&T wireless, well lets just say, his loved ones would be upset with me.
I'm seriously thinking of dumping my iPhone, and when Apple decides not to be AT&Ts B*TCH and use Verizon, I'll re-buy my iPhone and love it.
If I wanted to watch the Sling on Wifi, I'd use my laptop. And if I want to watch it on a cellular network, then Verizon Blackberry here I come.
Wouldn't it be a slap in the face to apple and at&t is the Palm Pre on sprint supports it over 3G.
nz @ May 12th 2009 9:56PM
Why does everyone think so highly of Verizon? I know they've got a pretty good network, but this is the same company that locked phones from using bluetooth for anything other than headsets, because they didn't want you to be able to transfer pictures and music without using their pay-for service.
blackacex2 @ May 12th 2009 11:27PM
Wow, I freaking KNEW this was EXACTLY what this app would be like. I knew flawless streaming of everything on cable to a device like this was too good to be true. Fact of the matter is sometimes certain things just seem like it's not quite time for them yet. My guess is they don't allow 3G because 3G is too slow to make for a pleasing experience with the app.
When cell networks offer 100mbps connectivity and devices the size of mobile phones have HD capable chipsets perhaps sling will have an app worth 30 dollars.
Right now 3G is too slow and the iphone is too weak to handle something as awesome as watching TV painlessly.
jjwatmyself @ May 12th 2009 11:47PM
The exact same mistake has been made with Skype for iPhone, disabling 3G.
In comparison, Skype for Windows Mobile and SlingPlayer for Windows Mobile DO have support for 3G and both work VERY well.
The mistake here is that removing 3G support on the iPhone is a serious blow in the mobile phone platform wars. Whomever made the decisions for Skype and SlingPlayer on iPhone, has one or more of the following characteristics:
a) Doesn't have a data plan on their personal phone
b) Thinks that iPhones are the only cell phones on the planet
c) Thinks that cellular based data communication (3G) doesn't exist
Stripping application functionality of the only two applictionas worth buying, is the reason why I don't own an iPhone. I happily use these apps on my Windows Mobile phone.
Steve Jobs, plesae take note of sales being negatively impacted by removal of 3G support. :(
Brian @ May 13th 2009 1:24PM
I was going to switch from cable to Dish Network when they released their Slingbox VIP922, but with no 3G support, I'll squash that plan. The only time I have a wifi connection is when I'm at home which makes the concept pointless for me.
mcornickm @ May 13th 2009 2:57PM
I made myself feel better today.
Downloaded Sling App free with Installous on Jail Broken phone.
Using 3gVoip mod I made the Sling App think it was always on wifi.
Streamed decent enough to watch content over T-Mobiles Edge network which I use the t-zones hack and have unlimited data.
So screw you AT&T, Apple, and Sling.
kcmurphy88 @ May 13th 2009 4:35PM
Well, the app is live today, after a fashion. Servers WAY overloaded, so It's hard to tell how it works. SlingCommunity site also overloaded -- probably people complaining about the slow service.