Waiting for
Battlestar Galactica to come home properly has been the source of
heartbreak more than once so far, but the upcoming
Caprica DVD appears to confirm rumors we'll be seeing a full series Blu-ray set sooner rather than later. Internet rumors have pegged the date as July 28, and on the prequel's DVD release a promo is included referencing the complete series coming soon on DVD and Blu-ray high def, so get your pennies together, while it will certainly be expensive this should be the one that's worth buying -- if they didn't get rid of the technology for
disc packaging yet.
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Britboyj27 @ Apr 15th 2009 3:47PM
Hopefully it LOOKS GOOD, unlike the HD DVD release, which looked like ass most of the time. I'm normally not one for grain reduction, but reduce a bit of the grain! Grain that looks fine at 1080i is shockingly bad at 1080p!
I will still buy it.
Dave @ Apr 15th 2009 2:05PM
Frackin AYE!!!
This is a BUY!!
shawnmos @ Apr 15th 2009 2:09PM
So say we all!
David S @ Apr 15th 2009 2:21PM
Before the whole planet jumps up and down, just remember what Stand DVD releases of this show look like, and what the HD broadcasts of this show looks like. The DVD releases are overcompressed garbage, and the HD broadcasts look craptastic too compared to other NBC/Universal HD broadcasts.
Hopefully they will give the show a proper Blu-Ray treatment, but I am seriously concerned over the video and audio quality of this release, moreso than perhaps any other TV series.
eugene @ Apr 15th 2009 10:19PM
No kidding. I'll be waiting for the reviews before putting money down.
I remember the craptastic HD-DVD release... the pilot was almost unwatchable due to the "grain" and the audio timing issues were inexcusable.
Eddie @ Apr 15th 2009 2:40PM
I'm surprised they aren't gonna release it in half season increments in order to maximize profits.
I'm sure there will be speciel editions for each of the next 20 years though.
Aaron @ Apr 15th 2009 3:15PM
Too bad the first two seasons looked just awful in HD. The makeup and sets especially look cheap cheap cheap.
TrentD @ Apr 17th 2009 11:27AM
Only one season was ever released in HD, so I'm betting you're just parroting what you've read on the internet, and haven't seen it for yourself. Am I right?
Eric @ Apr 15th 2009 3:45PM
Can't wait to see Lorne Greene in HD! :-D
riverside_guy @ Apr 15th 2009 3:59PM
Way too many people seem to equate HD only with things like live sports events. BSG was not shot on HD video.
People seem to forget that filmmakers for YEARS have had the ability to tailor the "look" of their work. Sometimes, they WANT to have a very grainy look.
My guess would be that this is EXACTLY what is going on with BSG... they WANT it dark and grainy. They WANT really dark shadows (black crush anyone) and to emphasis the look even further, tons of grain at times.
Face it, this is about that rag-tag collection of remains of the human race... and it ain't pretty.
Geckos, Inc. @ Apr 16th 2009 11:36PM
Actually, it was shot with HD digital cameras (the TV series at least... the miniseries was shot on film).
They added the grain on purpose. I think I read somewhere that the director used camera settings to get the grain so the originals are all grainy and this is why they couldn't apply a consistent level of grain from shot to shot in post-production. Oh well.
engage @ Apr 15th 2009 4:58PM
I'm with riverside on this one. Brings to mind BG's contemporary cousin, "The Shield," which also wasn't shot in HD but had (I think) a deliberately grainy look that suited the show's tone, If it ever gets transferred to Blu-ray, I expect it to retain that effect. Intense lead characters like Adama, Sol Tigh, and Vic Mackey practically demand film grain anyway, but most people look to Blu-ray for pristine images, e.g., "inky" blacks, very little mosquito noise, no crushing or banding, etc.
Equally important is the packaging, which by most accounts was abysmal on HD DVD. Based on that alone, I've passed up buying the box set numerous times, even when it dropped to 10 bucks. I highly doubt they'll make that mistake again; scathing reviews can have positive effects.
Geckos, Inc. @ Apr 17th 2009 8:57AM
I knew about the packaging issues but bought the Season 1 HD DVD set when it hit $15 or $18. Mine was not damaged but it's still kind of a pain to use and while it was cute that they cut off the corners like all the paper and cards in BSG, I don't think it was worth all the trouble it caused and I'd be quite suprised if they repeated it.
Also, I'm pretty sure it came with a little slip of paper basically saying that the grain was intentional and that it looks the way the creators wanted it to look.
Peter F @ Apr 15th 2009 8:38PM
Yeah, I bought the first season on HD-DVD....
DrafthouseFan @ Apr 15th 2009 10:06PM
I was lucky enough to see the last three hours (2 Eps) at the Alamo Drafthouse in Austin on a Sony 4k projection system. It upscaled beautifully, the detail was incredible. Do the math: on a 40' screen each pixel was 1/8" from 25' away. There were no artifacts or weird colors. Anyway, I'm looking forward to a BD release of the series.
http://blog.originalalamo.com/2009/03/26/battlestar-galactica-redux-at-village/
BRNDN @ Apr 16th 2009 2:25AM
echoing Riverside_guy, who is entirely correct, Battlestar producers really pushed the limits of the graininess allowed for television - it certainly wouldn't have been allowed on a larger network channel. Best show ever. So say we all.
TrentD @ Apr 17th 2009 11:29AM
Grain wouldn't have been allowed? Are you kidding? Link, please?
gecko @ Apr 16th 2009 2:07AM
uhhh . .. yes, BSG was shot in HD. At least, that what mr. moore says in the his podcasts.
JimC @ Apr 16th 2009 11:00AM
I think the graininess was for effect, to reflect the grit of the storyline but from what I remember, the space/CG sequences were sharp....
TrentD @ Apr 17th 2009 11:29AM
Correct.
Tyrone @ Apr 17th 2009 11:33PM
SO SAY WE ALL!!! It's about God's damn time!!!! I've been waiting for this for years!
Amun @ Apr 18th 2009 6:29PM
I'm still waiting on the Blu-Ray release of TNG... ='(